A piece of Talmud I have been thinking about all week often gets taught this way:
when one hears a fire truck going by with sirens wailing, one shouldn’t pray “please, God, let it not be my house burning” — either it is, or it isn’t, but the prayer won’t change whatever is already real. But where does this come from in Talmud? There were not fire engines back in the day. It comes from Berachot 9 and the idea that we should not say a prayer over something that has already happened or that is in vain. Sometimes this applies to medical diagnoses as well. We may already, for example, have cancer. We can’t change that now. We can manage how we respond to it. Rabbi Harold Kushner’s book is not “Why bad things happen to good people, but “when.” That doesn’t mean that the response is easy.
Similarly, Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel as cited in Gates of Prayer before the Amidah, as an intention, a kavanah which we used last night and this morning, said,
“Prayer cannot bring water to parched fields, or mend a broken bridge, or rebuild a ruined city; but prayer can water an arid soul, mend a broken heart, and rebuild a weakened will.”
“Pray as if everything depended on G-d; act as if everything depended on you. Who rise from prayer better person their prayer is answered.” (Gates of Prayer, page 157)
Last night we talked about what we would put in a “go bag.” We talked about the samovar in my office that was carefully carried from Russia by the Goldstein family. It is heavy, brass, beautiful. And you could pack things inside of it. For thousands of years Jews have been forced to leave and leave quickly, all the way back to the Exodus from Egypt, the story of which we begin to retell next week. Sometimes people leave because of threats of violence. Sometimes in times of famine. Sometimes because of natural disaster. Our Haggadah begins the story with these words: “Our father was a wandering Aramean.” which is actually how Deuteronomy begins to retell the story.
Often, I play a game with our kids in Torah School—and sometimes even with adults at our seder table. You have 18 minutes to leave Egypt. What are you taking with you. Sometimes we do it in alphabetical order.
This is no longer a drill. And not just in Southern California. We have had people displaced in our own community. Paul and Lynne Glaser in Ashville. Anita Silverman by fire at her senior living complex and now resettled but it took long months. And while her senior cat was rescued by the Schaumberg Fire Department, he was not welcome in her new apartment. Judy Richman from Del Webb when the tornado roared through last summer. The point is clear. Everyone should have a go bag. A list of what goes in that bag is included as a public service announcement at the end of this d’var Torah.
We have a prayer, “Ma Tovu Ohalecha Ya’akov.” How lovely our own dwelling places, O Jacob, our sanctuaries O Israel.” They are indeed lovely. But all too often we leave them and the belongings that are in them.
While the dwelling places are lovely, the most important thing is the lives they contain. This week I made phone calls to fire victims in California on behalf of Congregation Or Ami in Calabasas in the Palisades. It’s what we’ve been talking about all year. It’s about connections. Community. The Amen Effect. It was something I could do. From here.
Almost all the people I texted with or spoke with said the same this. They described themselves as lucky. Sad, maybe even depressed, missing family heirlooms and history and memories. Photos, art, Steinway pianos. And lucky.
Sometimes we think that the jewelry, the china, the silver are our legacies. I look around my living room. Things I have acquired over a lifetime. Over several generations. But they are not really legacies. What is a legacy?
Today’s portion is a bit of a challenge. Jacob is at the end of his life. He is “blessing” his sons.
“The God of your father, who helps you,
And Shaddai who blesses you
With blessings of heaven above,
Blessings of the deep that couches below,
Blessings of the breast and womb.
The blessings of your father
Surpass the blessings of my ancestors,
To the utmost bounds of the eternal hills.
May they rest on the head of Joseph,
On the brow of the elect of his brothers.”
What follows is a “blessing” for each son. But they feel much more like a blessing and a curse:
Benjamin is a ravenous wolf;
In the morning he consumes the foe,
And in the evening he divides the spoil.”
I don’t really want to be called a ravenous wolf as a blessing!
Perhaps the legacy, the blessing needs to be balanced. Balance is a key word. How do we maintain our balance when the world seems so out of kilter? What hope do we offer the next generations? How can I even dare to offer hope at times like these? What is the blessing in this moment?
As you know, Simon and I hike extensively. 38 states and 5 foreign countries. One of our most memorable hikes was from Topanga Canyon Road down to where the MASH filming site was in Malibu Creek State Park. For me, it was thrilling (and exhausting because it was hike down and then hike back up!) as a big fan of MASH. But perhaps what was most magical was creating memories with our adult kids. One other critical hike was in Estes Park, CO in the Rocky Mountain National Park. The ranger we were hiking with talked about the growth after the fire there now many years ago. Almost immediately, little ferns begin to grow. Those bright green shoots fill me with hope. Earlier this week I saw a blog post about precisely this. “Look for the miracles,” the woman, she herself had been through a devastating fire several years ago, wrote. “Look for the ferns.”
In another destructive fire, I was moved by a family who returned to their burned home to find the mezuzah still intact. I am considering buying mezuzot (I have ones in mind from Israel) to send to people at Or Ami. It is a way that we rededicate ourselves.
Other times I have quoted Mr. Roger who used to say: “Look for the helpers. You will always find people who are helping.” Our job is to find the helpers. Our job is to be the helpers. That’s how we “love our neighbors as ourselves.”
Looking for the miracles and looking for the helpers is how we build resiliency. It is how we build community. It is how we build hope. Even in the worst of this current crisis there is evidence of hope. Life will continue (for most). Life will be changed. There will be mourning and grief. But life will continue.
That mourning includes anticipatory mourning. Jacob did something else in this what could be called a “deathbed scene.” He left detailed instructions. He was to be buried not in Egypt but back in Canaan, back with his ancestors, with Abraham and Sarah, and Isaac in the cave of Machpelah. Joseph was able to convince Pharaoh to let him go to do this. All the dignitaries went too. In a scene reminiscent of this week’s state funeral held at the Washington National Cathedral with burial back in President Carter’s birthplace of Plains, Georgia.
But after the burial at Machpelah, Rabbi Menachem Creditor reminds us of a midrash on this portion. Joseph returned to the pit where his brothers once threw him in. (Genesis Rabbah 100:8). He transformed this moment from trauma—real trauma—to gratitude. This is not easy to do. Creditor continues, citing Rabbi Matthew Berkowitz “comparing it to survivors revisiting places of profound suffering: a soldier returning to a battlefield, a Holocaust survivor journeying to a concentration camp (Returning to Joseph’s Pit, 2025). These acts are not about erasing pain but about reclaiming agency and gratitude, even in the face of profound hurt.”
Joseph and his brothers mourned for Jacob after the burial for seven days. Ever wonder where the tradition of shiva comes from? Right here!
This “pre-planning” is a real gift to your family. A blessing, a legacy. We have talked about this before. Part of your legacy might be writing an ethical will, so your children and grandchildren know your values. Part of it maybe offering forgiveness for things said, and those not said. Part of it maybe making clear the funeral plans.
As we conclude this morning, we pray for healing. For ourselves, for our nation, for the people of California and Florida and Tennessee and North Carolina, for all of Am Yisrael including the hostages and the IDF and all those displaced from their homes, in the north of Israel, in Gaza, in Syria, in the Ukraine. ANd may we go forth from this book of Genesis stronger into Exodus where we are taught that we were wandering Arameans and slaves in the land of Egypt so that we have an obligation to be helpers, to welcome and love the widow, the orphan and the stranger. Chazak, chazak v’nitchazek.
Before Misheberach:
A Prayer for Firefighters and First Responders
Blessed are the hands that pull others from the flames,
scarred hands, calloused hands, trembling hands,
hands that grip hoses and axes,
hands that steady the world when it shakes.
Blessed is the courage that rises
stronger and higher than smoke —
the courage that steps into the chaos,
the courage that doesn’t flinch at the sound of breaking glass and metal,
that doesn’t stop even when the air burns and the ash falls.
Blessed is the heart that holds two truths at once:
the knowing that life is fragile,
and the stubborn faith that saving one life
is enough to hold up the universe.
We pray for the strength to carry the burden of this holy work.
For lungs that can breathe through the thickest soot.
For arms that will not falter,
even when the weight feels unbearable.
And we pray for their return.
For safe passage through the fire, the flood, the storm.
For nights where they can rest,
and mornings where they can hold their children
without the smell of smoke on their skin.
May they know that we see them,
that we hold them in the deepest parts of our hearts,
that their work is sacred,
like the flame that burns but does not consume.
Blessed are the ones who run toward the danger,
who wade into the waters,
who carve paths through the wreckage—
not because they are fearless,
but because they refuse to let fear have the final day.
Let them be guarded by something larger than themselves:
a voice in the wildness saying,
“You are not alone. You are not alone.”
And may the Holy One—by whatever name they call—
watch over them always,
and bring them back home.
Amen.
Sarah Tuttle Singer
Before Candle Lighting, both Friday night with two tapers and Saturday night for havdalah where those tapers become one “fire” with multiple wicks, usually representative of the community coming together:
Burning Hope by Paul Kipnes
Last night, two fires raged to within 5 miles my three holy places: our home, our synagogue Congregation Or Ami, and my father-in-law’s house. We packed, prepared to evacuate, only to see amazing firefighting teams knock the fires down. Lying in bed this morning, trying to figure out what comes next, I felt a flicker burning within. Which became …
Burning Hope
By Paul Kipnes
A flicker in the endless dusk,
A spark that whispers, Not yet lost.
Beneath the ash of dreams lifelong,
A stubborn ember, frail but strong.
It dances through the choking smoke,
Defying winds that would revoke
Its fragile right to blaze anew,
A beacon for the shattered few.
The world may press with heavy hands,
May scatter stone and barren sands,
But hope, though burning, never dies—
It smolders soft in weary eyes.
Overnight, as fears are cultivated,
It refuses to be evacuated.
A quiet hope to heal the earth,
Through morning’s light, it finds rebirth.
I saw this one of Facebook and didn’t snag the author, so I apologize. If I find it I will add the attribution. We talk a lot about balance at CKI. It is true of some of our basic elements as well. Water and fire. They are both necessary and can be destructive. She captures this:
FOR BLESSING AND NOT FOR CURSE
Creator of all things,
your creations fill the Earth.
With a simple glance I
behold the bounty
of your makings.
The living creatures of
flesh and breath,
the foliage which feeds,
the elemental powers which
we attribute to your actions.
We cannot simply pray
for abundance when too much
becomes a curse.
Reliant on the rain
whose waters sustain
in scarcity
delivers death with drought
in abundance
engulfs and drowns.
Reliant on the fire
whose heat warms
in scarcity
bears fatality with frost
in abundance
engulfs and incinerates.
The same water which
fuels can flood.
The same fire which
fuels can destroy.
We cannot pray them away.
Creator of all things,
we pray for balance
blessing, not curse
life, not death
satiety, not want
knowing one shifting wind
can change our fate.
Go bags:
From the Westchester County Website:
- Bottled water and nonperishable food, such a s granola bars
- Personal hygiene items (toothbrush, toothpaste, deodorant, wet wipes, etc)
- Flashlight, hand-crank or battery-operated AM/FM radio, and extra batteries
- Portable cell phone charger
- Notepad, pen/pencil, and marker
- Local street maps (paper version)
- Spare home/vehicle keys
- Whistle or bell
- First aid kit
- Dust mask to reduce inhalation of dust and other debris
- Work gloves
- A change of clothing (long sleeve shirt/pants, rain gear, sturdy footwear, etc.)
- Copies of important documents (insurance/medical cards, contact lists, identification, marriage and birth certificates, etc.) in a portable, waterproof container or plastic bag
- Back-up medical/assistive equipment and supplies
- A list of the medications you take, why you take them, and the dosages
- Cash, in small bills
- Supplies for your service animal or pet
In my go bag, I will also put one piece of irreplacebale jewelry that was my grandmother’s, a daisy pearl pin and a piece of silver that rode out the Chicago Fire in 1871. My daughter plans to take her first Disney medal.